Wedding Venues For Cherry Grove, NY

Cherry Grove has been a haven for couples who found each other on its boardwalks since the 1950s, and many still dream of celebrating with the friends they made there. Soundview Caterers welcomes Grove couples to a private Bayville wedding venue on the North Shore, where the Long Island Sound forms the backdrop from ceremony through last dance.

100% Satisfaction

View our work

Browse Wedding Services

contact us

Top 10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Wedding Venue For Cherry Grove, NY

A beautifully decorated event space with chandeliers and string lights, perfect among wedding venues for Long Island, NY. The table is elegantly set with glassware, a tall floral centerpiece of pink and white flowers, and candlesticks. The ambiance is warm and inviting.

A Waterfront Wedding Venue for Cherry Grove Couples

The Grove has no roads and very limited space for a large wedding, so many couples plan the big day on the mainland. With us, you are the only wedding on the property during your celebration. Up to about 300 guests can join you. Chefs prepare everything in our kitchen, a dedicated coordinator manages your timeline, and the essentials are covered: tables, chairs, basic linens and cleanup. Our contracts are transparent and free of hidden fees, so you can plan with confidence.

Flexibility:

Enjoy the flexibility of customizable packages tailored to suit your unique preferences and budget, ensuring your wedding day reflects your individual style.

Attention to Detail:

Experience meticulous attention to detail at every stage of planning, from initial consultation to the flawless execution of your event, leaving no stone unturned.

Seamless Coordination:

Relax and enjoy a stress-free planning process with our expert team seamlessly coordinating every aspect of your wedding day, allowing you to savor every moment with your loved ones.

Luxurious wedding venue on Long Island, NY, featuring a stunning banquet hall with elegant chandeliers and round tables adorned with pink and purple floral arrangements. The room is framed by a grand doorway with intricate details and mirrors, creating a sophisticated atmosphere.

10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Wedding Venue For Cherry Grove, NY

Cherry Grove takes its name from the black cherry trees that grew there when Archer and Elizabeth Perkinson bought the land in 1868. A century and a half later, it is one of the best known LGBTQ resort communities in the country, a place of beach cottages, wooden walks and lifelong friendships. Couples who spent their summers in the Grove often want a reception that honors that spirit: joyful, a little theatrical and surrounded by water. Our ballroom and cocktail room look out on the Long Island Sound, giving you a wide waterfront view on the North Shore.

Grove weddings tend to blend chosen family with relatives who may never have taken the Sayville ferry. That mix makes a central, comfortable setting important. Some couples host a casual welcome on the island, maybe drinks by the bay, and then bring everyone together for a full wedding with us. Others hold the ceremony and reception here so no one has to plan around ferry times. We also host engagement parties, rehearsal dinners and bridal showers, which can be a nice way to introduce your island friends to the rest of the family before the big day.

Your cocktail hour opens with an Italian grazing station and trays of hot and cold bites passed by our staff. Pick hot stations that suit you: pasta, a seafood bar, a wok, a mash-tini bar or a butcher block. Enhancements include a seafood boat, a raw bar, sushi, and caviar served with frozen vodka. At dinner, raise a champagne toast, then serve plated Atlantic salmon, filet mignon, chicken crusted with herbs or a vegetarian option. Finish with your wedding cake plus sorbet cones or a Viennese spread, then send guests off with a late-night NY hot dog cart or milk and cookies.

Popular Saturdays fill 12 to 18 months out, so start early if you want peak summer. That said, many Grove friends treasure their July weekends on the island, and a Friday, a Sunday or a winter date can be both kinder to them and easier to secure. Your photographer, florist and musicians are welcome with proof of insurance, and our team handles every plate and pour. Share dietary needs such as vegan, gluten-free, kosher-style or allergies early, and confirm your final guest count 14 days ahead so the kitchen can prepare everything fresh.

A couple kisses under a canopy on a beach during their wedding ceremony at sunset. Guests seated on either side clap and cheer. A person stands behind them officiating. The ocean and sky create a beautiful golden backdrop, making it one of the most picturesque wedding venues Long Island NY offers.

Choose Soundview Caterers for an Incredible Wedding Experience

Picture your Grove friends raising a glass with the Sound behind you. Book a private tour of our Bayville venue by calling 516-202-5700, or text 516-908-6031 to find a time. We will walk you through the ballroom, ceremony options and our After Party Lounge.

Have a question?

Couples with Grove roots often take engagement or pre-wedding photos on the island: along the boardwalks of the town center, outside the shingled Community House and Theatre, or among the holly trees of the Sunken Forest just to the west. Guests visiting for the wedding weekend can explore Fire Island National Seashore, whose protected beaches wrap around the hamlet, before heading to the North Shore for your reception.

Explore Cherry Grove

Spots that matter to couples and guests with a connection to the Grove.

  • Cherry Grove, New York: Read about the Grove's neighborhoods, its ferry from Sayville and its long-running Memorial Day and Labor Day traditions.
  • Carrington House: The Lewis Walk cottage where theater director Frank Carrington hosted artists, now recognized on the National Register for LGBTQ history.
  • Sunken Forest at Sailors Haven: A globally rare maritime holly forest with a boardwalk trail, a lovely spot for a quiet walk before the wedding weekend.
  • Fire Island: Background on the barrier island across the Great South Bay, handy for guests visiting the Grove for the first time.
  • History of Fire Island National Seashore: How preservationists saved the Sunken Forest and won federal protection for the beaches beside Cherry Grove.

Cherry Grove Wedding Venue FAQs

Can Cherry Grove couples hold both the ceremony and reception at your venue?

Yes. We can host your ceremony on site and then move guests straight into cocktail hour and the reception, all in one building with views of the Sound. Since we hold only one event at a time, the space is entirely yours, and your coordinator keeps each transition smooth.

Our families have never been to the Grove. Is a mainland reception easier for them?

Many couples find it is. Instead of coordinating ferries to Fire Island, relatives can gather at our Bayville venue on the North Shore. You can still celebrate the Grove with a smaller island gathering earlier in the weekend, and your photographer can capture both.

Could we host an engagement party for our Grove friends before the wedding?

We would be glad to. An engagement party with butler-passed bites, a few hot stations and an open bar is a fun way to bring island friends and family together. Bridal showers and rehearsal dinners can be booked as separate events too, each with its own menu.

Can we bring in a drag performer or cabaret singer as wedding entertainment?

Outside entertainers are welcome as long as they provide proof of insurance. Many couples combine a performer with a DJ, and our After Party Lounge, run in conjunction with Ultimate Sound DJs, keeps the music going for an extra hour downstairs with LED-illuminated lounge furniture and the open bar.

When should a Grove couple book a summer Saturday?

Most couples reserve 12 to 18 months ahead for prime Saturdays. If you are flexible, Fridays, Sundays and winter dates are easier to find, and your Fire Island friends may thank you for not taking a July beach weekend. Call 516-202-5700 to check open dates.

Ready to start planning your dream wedding? Make your dream day a reality with Soundview Caterers!

Request Pricing & Book a Free Private Tour

Tell us your date and guest count and our event team will follow up. Prefer to talk? Call 516-202-5700.